Nick’s Picks: Colonial Downs picks August 23, 2025
He’s probably the only public handicapper who’s ‘capped every race at Colonial Downs since Day One, and he’s back for more in 2025: Nick’s Picks returns with picks and analysis for every day of the Colonial meet.
- DATE/POST TIME: August 23/12:30 p.m.
- RACES: 9
- CARRYOVERS: None
RACE 1
Female $16k maiden claimers sprint on the turf with a chance for several from the dirt to foil turf standouts.
5. Naval Hospital | Swung forward and backward in his first Colonial start but look for a good start with Ashton returning for Casse. Bettered several here. |
2. Rancho Vista | Ran the same in her only turf start what she has done on the dirt many times. Whatever the surface, should be in the mix. |
10. Song and a Breeze | How good was McGoey’s filly only turf start? It was up in class so hard to tell. Rebounded with a solid start level near this on the dirt. |
RACE 2
Female MSW sprint on the dirt for two-year-olds with the few starts among the field only happening at Colonial. Six make their debut.
2. Sudden Squall | Why is this filly only a $4k purchase last fall? West has certainly put her to task in the mornings at Turfway. Husband rides. |
1. Athenix | Campbell’s filly has the best start among the field on the dirt. His Good Magic-filly should be a popular pick with Sanchez aboard. |
9. Light de Night | From the Fasig-Tipton Midlantic 2yo sale in May with price to Colts Neck works to a Colonial start. |
RACE 3 – Dolley Madison Stakes
The $125,000 Dolley Madison debuts for two-year-old Maryland/Virginia breds going 5 & 1/2 furlongs on the turf with a potential rematch.
5. Hark Theangelssing | Seeing that the rematch comes over to turf, reaching out for a Trombetta filly that has a win at Colonial in a deep field. |
3. Just Philtored | Trombetta in a position to sweep the exacta adding the Keswick winner on dirt trying the turf the first time. |
4. Slewperstitus | On paper, its nearly a coin flip on which stake Bailes’s filly should run but expecting to go here. Either stake will be a turf adventure. |
RACE 4 – Jamestown Stakes
The $125,000 Jamestown for two-year-olds returns to Colonial but now adds Maryland restricted entrants that dominate the field.
2. Doubting Thomas | A Larry Johnson homebred that won with space in his debut, comes back to the turf and returns Ruiz. |
6. Karate Island | Good rally in debut and shows a good work in the meantime. |
1. Slewperstitus | A compelling reason for Bailes to run his filly here is the 73 Beyer she earned in her 2nd race, better than these boys. |
RACE 5
A restricted maiden optional $50k claiming race goes a turf mile draws eleven two-year-olds with an August 2 race relevant.
2. Undertaker | A good race to ignore percentages and seek bloodlines like this Cairo Prince colt that found the lead in his first start. |
5. Rocky Lagoon | Lightner’s gelding ran well for a long way in his debut. Look for a better finish coming back at the same distance. |
1. Smols | Part of the double dead heat in late July at Colonial for third. Might earn it by himself this go around. |
RACE 6
A Virginia-restricted “nonwinners of two other than” turf mile draws ten colts and geldings for a field with early speed.
8. Jack’s Legend | Bettered many in this field in a nearly identical race last month. After breaking his maiden at Colonial in his debut has run well. |
7. Wheneveruremember | Remember Larry Johnson’s homebred breaking his maiden at Colonial? Has shown run late and stretches out from 5 1/2 furlongs. |
9. Covert Kat | On paper, Trombetta’s horse should find the lead but not comfortably, yet coming back to a mile could play in his favor. |
RACE 7
The sprint for females on the turf in an MSW inserts three new starters and two first timers among past Colonial starters.
6. Mun Mun Can Run | Gallardo gets the mount for a filly new to the Cibelli barn that lost to Shameless Bride opening weekend and adds blinkers. |
5. Sporting Lady | Brion’s bridesmaid has finished second in her last five starts going back to Colonial last summer. Safe place bet. |
1. Destination | The layoff didn’t change the form for Russell’s older filly that has had the lead in every one of her five career starts. |
RACE 8
In a turf mile, $50k claimers “nonwinners of two” includes four in the field that broke their maiden in their last start.
7. Feral’s Joy | Duarte’s gelding has been within a length of a win in his last two starts after a layoff. Sired by Kitten’s Joy. |
2. Summer Vibes | A Good Magic (Curlin) gelding shortens to a mile after being claimed in a win for Liberty House Racing and Gaudet. |
8. Transactional Guy | Another claim this time for Amaty Racing and Jose Gallegos in a win. After not taking long to win, stretches to a mile today. |
RACE 9
The finale offers eleven $40k maiden claimers going 1 1/16 on the turf with varying level of class above and below this level.
2. Black Empire | At this level and distance, a Malibu Moon gelding returns Arrieta aboard who was within a length of a win in his last start. |
6. Tasker | Whether in MSW or maiden claming, ran well on the turf at this distance at Laurel. The skills of Meyers’ Lemon Drop Kid should carry. |
1. Then What | Comes out of MSW with Sanchez aboard on a Street Sense journeyman making his fifth start in five different venues. |
Picture of the day
Spotless
Just Philtored maintained her perfect 2-for-2 record when she held off Slewperstitus to win the Keswick last out. She’ll try to make it 3-for-3 Saturday. She’s 6-5 on the morning line for Saturday’s Dolley Madison and will have Mychel Sanchez up for trainer Mike Trombetta.

LATEST NEWS