We asked some ‘cappers — some fictional, some not — to pick the Kentucky Derby.¬† Click on each tab to reveal their selections.

[su_tabs][su_tab title=”CONSENSUS“]
  1.  American Pharoah
  2. Dortmund
  3. Frosted
  4. Mubtaahij
[/su_tab] [su_tab title=”Derby Bill Watson”]former Colonial Downs on-air handicapper

  1. American Pharoah
  2. International Star (scratched)
  3. Mubtaahij
  4. Dortmund[/su_tab]
[su_tab title=”Nick Hahn”]The Racing Biz Virginia correspondent, radio host

  1. American Pharoah
  2. Dortmund
  3. Firing Line
  4. Materiality
[/su_tab][su_tab title=”Gary Quill”]The Racing Biz Maryland handicapper

  1. Frosted
  2. Dortmund
  3. International Star (scratched)
  4. American Pharoah
[/su_tab][su_tab title=”Ted Black”]The Racing Biz correspondent

  1. Mubtaahij
  2. International Star (scratched)
  3. Upstart
  4. Frosted[/su_tab]
[su_tab title=”Nathan Detroit & Miss Adelaide”]Fictional characters who have the horse right here

  1. Materiality
  2. American Pharoah
  3. Far Right
  4. Upstart
[/su_tab][su_tab title=”Handicapping machine”]We asked our computer to spit out the winner, and…

  1. Dortmund
  2. Upstart
  3. Frosted
  4. Bolo[/su_tab][/su_tabs]